Identical twin brothers, Landon and Luke, start their college experiences at the same university but in very different social circles. Landon joins a fraternity and majors in political science/pre-law. Luke focuses on pre-med, baseball, and his girlfriend Lauren who majors in pre-pharmacy. Their freshman year is filled with challenges both in and out of the classroom. Landon falls for a forbidden love while giving his brother a score to settle.
The story of their summer canyon experience spreads across campus as Landon paints a much different picture than Luke about what happened. His fraternity brothers consider him a hero for saving his twin brother. He shares his story with all his sorority dates who consider him a much more polished version of the shy baseball player, Luke. Luke and Lauren cringe every time they hear the latest more embellished version of Landon's story. He even touts himself to be "the dangerous twin" until real danger bonds him and his brother to battle a greater threat.