Literally bumping into her blind date isn't exactly how Jenny Meyer imagined meeting Nick Bryson. And if he notices she's a bit rusty in the dating department, he's right. So when the scoundrel offers to coach her in much-needed dating lessons, she decides to go for it. Taking him up on the offer provides more fun than she's had in a long time and as she gets to know him, she rises to the challenge of proving to Nick that love is a worthwhile endeavor.

Fake dating soon becomes a problem for cynical Nick when he starts to worry about Jenny taking his so-called lessons seriously and applying them to the male population. It occurs to him that maybe he doesn't have all the answers about relationships. He does discover that he wants Jenny for himself, with no pretense. Once she turns the tables on him, Nick becomes the student while Jenny teaches him about true love.